Prop 40 Didn’t Lose Because California Loves Billionaires

Statement from the Peace and Freedom Party

Prop 40, the one-time 5% tax on California’s billionaires, was defeated. But it didn’t lose because working people oppose taxing the rich. It lost because fewer than three dozen billionaires and their allies outspent supporters by roughly 10 to 1, shattering records for ballot campaign spending. Top Democratic Party leaders gave them cover, while billionaire-backed measures muddied the ballot and helped convince enough voters that Prop 40 would hurt the working class. 

This is a story about the lengths the capitalist class will go to preserve its wealth and power. Capitalism allows a tiny, ultrawealthy few to accumulate wealth from the labor of working people and the exploitation of the planet, then turn that wealth into political power. They will spend hundreds of millions to protect their own fortunes rather than contribute even a fraction of what they owe to the people whose labor created that wealth. 

Prop 40’s defeat is capitalism working as designed. The permanent answer is socialism, where the working people control the wealth we create. 

Working people didn’t reject taxing the rich

Look at the rest of the ballot. Nearly 60% voted Yes on Prop 3, which makes higher taxes on top earners permanent. That’s more than 7.3 million votes to keep taxing the rich. And more than 5.7 million people voted Yes on Prop 40.

Look at who backed it. In a late-October Berkeley IGS poll, households earning under $40,000 a year supported Prop 40 by 54% (yes) to 31% (no). Households earning $200,000 or more opposed it by 63% (no)  to 30% (yes). The people with the least were the most ready to tax the people with the most.

But as the billionaires’ ads flooded every screen, support slipped from 52% to 46% in a single month. The problem was never what working people want. The problem is who holds the money and power to shape the outcome.

Billionaires bought the campaign, the politicians, and the cover

They bought the campaign. To defeat the tax, Google co-founder Sergey Brin founded Building a Better California, which raised more than $333 million. Brin contributed $102 million. Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt $40.2 million, and venture capitalist John Doerr $40 million. The Yes side, led by the healthcare workers of SEIU-UHW, raised just $32 million. Brin’s $102 million was less than 1% of what he would have owed.

They flooded voters with lies. The opposition painted Prop 40 as a “Trojan horse” that would tax working people’s retirement savings and allow politicians to expand the tax to everyone. They deliberately omitted a key legal limit: expanding the tax would likely require another vote. The billionaires manufactured fear to turn the tax into a supposed threat for working people.  

They rewrote the rules. Billionaires put Propositions 41 and 42 on the ballot as “poison pills” designed to undermine Prop 40. Under California law, if conflicting measures both pass, the one with more Yes votes wins. Prop 41 failed, but Prop 42 passed, writing a ban on new state taxes on stocks, financial assets, and other personal property into the California Constitution. They sold it as protecting your retirement savings, even though Prop 40 already exempted retirement accounts and pensions, with narrow exceptions for the very largest accounts. When working people asked for 5%, once, the billionaires moved to block future attempts. Voters can repeal Prop 42, but the lesson stands: the rich can and will use their wealth to rewrite the rules.

They controlled the media narrative. The same class that funded the No side owns major outlets that told you about it. The Washington Post, owned by Jeff Bezos, ran editorials warning that California “will miss billionaires when they’re gone.” One leaned on a study that the tax’s own designer said modeled the wrong tax. Billionaire-owned media pushed their owners’ side. Under capitalism, the people being reported on own the outlets doing the reporting.

They bankrolled the politicians. Gov. Gavin Newsom promised in January that the tax “will be defeated.” He tried to keep it off the ballot. Then he endorsed Prop 42, the billionaire-funded measure built to kill it. Xavier Becerra, now governor-elect, opposed it too. The San Francisco Democratic Party opposed it. This isn’t an accident. Billionaire money is the price of high office in both capitalist parties.

They recruited cover. Newsom’s chief of staff told the New York Times how they planned to frame its defeat: “It’s going to be Planned Parenthood, doctors, teachers, and labor killed it.” But don’t let them erase our side. Nurses, healthcare workers, the California Labor Federation, and the State PTA backed Prop 40, even as leading Democrats opposed it. If you’ve voted for Democrats hoping they’d stand up to billionaires, notice who stood where. This was the party’s leadership against its own base. 

Splitting Prop 3 from Prop 40 protected billionaire fortunes

Some on the progressive side treated Prop 3 and Prop 40 as rivals. The teachers union put Prop 3 first and called Prop 40 unsustainable, even though voters could pass both. Nobody had to choose.

And they don’t do the same thing. Prop 3 taxes high incomes. Billionaire fortunes sit mostly in stock, which isn’t taxed until it’s sold or pays out. Splitting the two left billionaire fortunes untouched. Capitalism makes schools and hospitals fight over whatever the wealthy allow. We reject that game.

Their fortunes come from our work

California’s billionaires grew their wealth by $487 billion in a single year, reaching more than $2 trillion. Even at supporters’ estimate of about $100 billion, a 5% tax, once, equals about one-fifth of a single year’s gains. Nvidia made $120 billion in profit in its latest fiscal year. Google’s parent company, Alphabet, made $132 billion in 2025.

That wealth doesn’t fall from the sky. From 1979 to 2019, U.S. workers’ productivity grew 59.7%, while a typical worker’s pay grew 15.8%. The gains flowed to the top. The planet pays too: the richest 1% produce more than twice the carbon pollution of the poorest half of humanity.

Meanwhile, about 2 million Californians face losing health coverage from federal Medi-Cal cuts. Even the state budget rides on billionaire stock gains. The state’s own nonpartisan budget office warns that recent revenue depends on an AI-driven stock market that may not last. A budget built on their profits is a budget built on their terms.

And a one-time 5% tax is hardly radical. From 1944 to 1963, the top federal income tax rate stayed above 90%. Yet billionaires were willing to spend more than $400 million on advertising, political influence and campaigns to protect their wealth instead of funding healthcare and other public needs.  

The problem is capitalism. The answer is socialism.

We said Yes on 40. We also said it wouldn’t solve everything. Only reorganizing society will.

One-time relief can’t fund needs that never end. A permanent tax on the ultra-wealthy is better. But even permanent taxes leave billionaires owning the economy, owning the media, and buying the politicians who write the rules.

Socialism removes the source of that power. Socialism is a political and economic system where working people own and control what we produce, for the benefit of all. In California, that means:

  • Industry and natural resources owned socially and managed democratically.
  • Free, quality public health care for everyone, with profit taken out of it.
  • Free public education, from preschool through graduate school.
  • On the way there, a steeply graduated tax on all forms of concentrated wealth, including stocks and bonds.

The Defeat of Prop 40 shows the fight ahead

Despite the historic blue tsunami, Prop 40’s defeat in one of the country’s most liberal-leaning states exposes the limits of relying on the Democratic Party to challenge billionaire power. Look at who funds the party’s leaders. Sequoia Capital billionaire Michael Moritz gave $2.5 million to Gov. Newsom’s Prop 50 campaign in 2025, then helped bankroll the fight against Prop 40. After the June primary, billionaires including Snap’s Evan Spiegel and developer Rick Caruso gave Xavier Becerra the maximum donation. Stewart Resnick, another billionaire who paid to defeat Prop 40, gave to Becerra’s campaign too.

When working people’s interests collide with the wealthy’s, Democratic leaders side with the people who fund them. In the face of prop 40, Billionaires are creating new institutions to protect their dollar democracy. Y Combinator CEO Garry Tan, who also gave Becerra the maximum donation, is among the backers of California Renewal, a planned nine-figure endowment-style fund meant to shape California elections for decades. This new fund is built to conceal donor information and deepen billionaire influence over elections in the state. 

To defeat this dollar-democracy and the right-wing agenda once and for all, we need an independent socialist movement. Real change has never come from the ballot box alone. It comes from the mass movement to take on the billionaire class. 

Organize for a California for the people, not the billionaires

You’re not alone. In June’s primary, independent socialist candidates won about 1.5 million votes across five statewide races. Let’s organize together to build a California for us, not them.

So no, Prop 40 isn’t losing because you love billionaires. It’s losing because capitalism lets a few billionaires buy the outcome. They have the money. We have the numbers. Let’s organize.

About the Peace and Freedom Party

The Peace and Freedom Party is California’s independent socialist party, founded in 1967. Born out of the Black liberation and anti-war movements, we fight for socialism, democracy, ecology, feminism, racial equality, and internationalism. We represent the working class: the people who keep California running but don’t own the companies that profit from our work. Join us in building a California for working people, not the billionaires.

Peace and Freedom Party © 2026. All Rights Reserved.  ·  Cookie Policy